The Borda count can be combined with an Instant Runoff procedure to create hybrid election methods that are called Nanson method and Baldwin method.
Nanson method
The Nanson method is based on the original work of the mathematician Edward J. Nanson.
Nanson’s method eliminates those choices from a Borda count tally that are at or below the average Borda count score, then the ballots are retallied as if the remaining candidates were exclusively on the ballot.
This process is repeated if necessary until a single winner remains.
Baldwin method
This variant was devised by Joseph M. Baldwin and works like this:
Candidates are voted for on ranked ballots as in the Borda count. Then, the points are tallied in a series of rounds. In each round, the candidate with the fewest points is eliminated, and the points are re-tallied as if that candidate were not on the ballot.
Satisfied and failed criteria
The Nanson method and the Baldwin method satisfy the Condorcet criterion: since Borda always gives any existing Condorcet winner more than the average Borda points, the Condorcet winner will never be eliminated. They do not satisfy the independence of irrelevant alternatives criterion, the monotonicity criterion, the participation criterion, the consistency criterion and the independence of clones criterion, while they do satisfy the majority criterion, the mutual majority criterion, the Condorcet loser criterion, reversal symmetry and the Smith criterion.
Use of Nanson and Baldwin
Nanson’s method was used in city elections in the U.S. town of Marquette, Michigan in the 1920s. It was formally used by the Anglican Diocese of Melbourne and in the election of members of the University Council of the University of Adelaide. It was used by the University of Melbourne until 1983.
Note
- See: Australian electoral reform and two concepts of representation
- TSA / Luggage Locks - LuggageOnline Luggage Online offers Luggage Locks & Security by Lewis N. Clark, Victorinox Swiss Army, Travelon, Eagle Creek, Briggs & Riley.
- Travel Security Items - Luggage Locks luggage locks, luggage lock, lock luggage, locks luggage, bag lock, lock bag, lock bags, duffel bag lock, duffel bag locks, lock duffel bag, austin house,
- TSA Lock and Luggage Locks TSA Luggage Locks, baggage, luggage grips and accessories for Airport Security.
- Luggage Locks and Travel Security We have a brief article that explores some concerns surrounding travel security and luggage locks. Visit Designer Handbags 101 for more information.
- Corporate Travel Safety Online Store :: Search Alert TSA Luggage Lock Each SearchAlert TSA Luggage Lock has a special identification mark alerting the TSA that they can open this lock without destroying it.
- TSA Luggage Locks TSA Lock TSA Luggage Belts Travel Sentry TSA Luggage Locks TSA Lock TSA Luggage Belts Travel Sentry Certified Travel Sentry luggage padlocks TSA locks, searchalert, travel sentry, travelsentry,
- Armchair World: Luggage Locks The locks on your luggage are not that secure when it comes to the professional thief or manipulator and are really no more than a deterrent.
- Luggage Locks, Luggage Straps & Luggage Labels Luggage and suitcase accessories including luggage straps, locks and tags at ifsogo.com The Travel Accessories Superstore – UK online store.
- MySpaceTV Videos: Picking four different TSA luggage locks by Graham Picking four different TSA luggage locks by Graham Watch it on MySpace Videos.
- Why is it so Hard to Find Good Luggage Locks? Everyone who travels should use luggage locks. So for every suitcase sold, there should be a lock sold. But somehow it is a lot easier to find a good
- Luggage Locks We understand that when traveling you need the safety and security of identifying your baggage, without a tremendous expense or hassle.
- TSA Luggage Lock (set of 2) - Travel TSA Luggage Lock (set of 2) This new TSA approved security lock features a 3 digit keyless resettable combination lock with a TSA approved master keyhole on
Tags: Uncategorized by admin
No Comments »